Episode 111: Natalie Maribel | The Night She Didn’t Come Home

On a quiet Saturday night in 1999, 24-year-old Natalie Maribel stepped out to grab diapers and never came home. Her car was found sitting in a grocery store parking lot, untouched, but Natalie was gone. What investigators uncovered in the days that followed would unravel a marriage, expose hidden secrets, and shock an entire church community.