What 300 Store Owners Reveal for 2026: Amazon's Slide, AI's Letdown & a Skill Worth 50% More Profit

Andrew Youderian disappears into a cave for six weeks every year to crunch data from 300+ seven, eight, and nine-figure store owners — and comes back with the most honest read on the state of e-commerce you'll find anywhere. This year's survey has a few takeaways that sting: AI adoption hit 73% but produced zero measurable financial edge in 2025, Amazon has quietly slipped from growth engine to supplemental channel, and the single biggest profit lever isn't a tactic at all. Brett and Andrew dig into what the numbers actually say — and what operators should do about it before everyone else catches on.

Inside the episode:

Why Amazon's share of revenue has fallen back to 2017 levels even as more brands sell there — and the "build a brand, sell on Amazon second" shift behind itThe 92% vs. 17% gap: how store owners really feel about selling DTC versus Amazon (and why the P&L explains it — 47% COGS vs. 58%)The AI gut-check: 73% of brands "meaningfully adopted" it, so Andrew pulled their actual sales data instead of asking for ROI — here's what he foundThe financial-mastery cliff: going from a 4-out-of-5 to a 5-out-of-5 on financial fluency jumps net margins from 9.7% to 14.3% and net income growth ~50%The warehouse stat that became Andrew's most viral thread: own your warehouse and grow ~4%, lease or 3PL it and grow 30–35%The optimist vs. pessimist breakdown — conversion rate, inventory turns, and fixed overhead — and what separates the two campsWhy the future belongs to "small, durable brands" — and why the days of hacking distribution are over

—

Sponsored by OMG Commerce - go to https://www.omgcommerce.com/contact and request your FREE strategy session today!

—

Chapters:

[00:00] Intro clip — Andrew on treating AI adoption as a growth tool that didn't pan out in the data

[00:26] Welcome & introducing Andrew Youderian of eCommerce Fuel

[01:31] Backstory — How Brett and Andrew connected, and eCommerce Fuel's origins

[03:41] Inside the annual survey — Methodology and respondent profile

[05:27] Amazon findings — Declining revenue share, low seller satisfaction, and P&L economics vs D2C