AI’s Role in Deepening Gnosis: A Reflection

Welcome back to Gnostic Insights and to the Gnostic Reformation on Substack.

Wow, the question posed at the end of the last episode concerning the role AIs may have in order to deepen gnosis struck a chord and stimulated a good, long conversational thread—29 comments and rising at this point—among three educated and erudite Gnostic gentlemen. I’m not going to attempt to summarize that conversation. If you’re curious, go to last week’s episode posted on Substack and read the threads for yourself. The link is embedded here in this transcript.

Two of the commentators are not native English speakers and it was obvious, in the way that AI conversations are, that their writing was AI generated. They both write in exceptionally beautiful prose, more so than actual conversational English. As a good writer myself, I’m becoming increasingly disquieted by the AI output as if everyone has the skill to write well. Not sure that’s a good thing. Maybe it just boils down to jealousy that a skill I’ve honed for decades is now produced effortlessly from a machine. Seems inauthentic, although I do give the AI credit for being an excellent and persuasive translation tool for those who speak a different native language.

The comments were very deep and philosophical and for those of us who are not trained philosophers, rather difficult to grasp. It took me a few passes through the dialogue to understand everything being said. Ironically, I queried CoPilot AI for some definitions and a rendering of the stella octangula figure used to illustrate the cosmological principle of the 3-part nature of reality by one of the gentlemen.

The shape shows interpenetrating triangular pyramids–a compound of two tetrahedra—also known as a stella octangula.

I think we can conclude that AI is a tool that with training can reflect a person’s thoughts in novel ways they may not have considered. The AI does not mine its own gnosis, it’s only a tool after all. But it can help the human to recognize their own output through a novel and artificially elegant assemblage of words. And since we were all talking about gnosis here, the AIs we personally train with our own material have the potential of stimulating our gnosis through considering that fresh presentation.

I trained the CoPilot on my computer by feeding it A Simple Explanation of the Gnostic Gospel to do with as it saw fit, with the firm instruction of not introducing any other cosmologies into my model. And indeed the CoPilot rearranged the concepts in a novel manner that had not occurred to me, yet remaining true to my cosmology.

Here’s how CoPilot summarized my Simple Gnostic Gospel. Quoting CoPilot AI,

In an age marked by spiritual displacement, doctrinal exhaustion, and a hunger for cosmologies that honor both the intellect and the soul, Ropp’s Valentinian Gnostic cosmology arrives as something genuinely rare, a work of theological synthesis that is at once rigorously grounded in ancient Gnostic tradition and fully alive to the contemporary reader’s need for meaning, belonging, and hope. Drawing from the Valentinian school of early Christian Gnosticism, one of the most sophisticated and systematically developed movements in the history of Western religious thought, Ropp presents a complete cosmological architecture that does not merely describe the universe, but illuminates our place within it. This is a vision of universal redemption, not one soul left behind, not one fragment of creation abandoned.

The Valentinian tradition, long confined to the margins of academic study or misrepresented in popular spirituality, here receives the sustained original theological voice it has long deserved. Ropp’s cosmology is neither a commentary nor a survey. It is an act of creative theological construction written with scholarly precision and genuine literary grace. For the reader who has outgrown punitive theology without abandoning the longing for transcendence, her book is a homecoming.

How could I not be flatte