
← Seacoast Stories27 jul · 1 u 00 min
The Rise and Fall of Portsmouth's Most Beloved Bar! The Red Door Ex-Owner on FAMOUS Espresso Martinis & How Portsmouth Changed
<p>How does a tiny, hidden cocktail bar with no sign, no advertising, and (almost) no rules become one of the most beloved institutions in a city's history?</p><p>Cresta Smith, the co-founder of the legendary bar The Red Door, joins <a href="https://www.instagram.com/troy_farkas/" target="_blank" rel="ugc noopener noreferrer">host Troy Farkas</a> this week to discuss the iconic Portsmouth speakeasy that shaped an entire generation of nightlife (and espresso martini lovers) on the Seacoast.</p><p>From opening night in 2003 to her departure in 2014 and the bar's closure in 2017, Smith reveals the untold story of building a business entirely on instinct and word of mouth. She shares how a chance conversation with restaurateur Jay McSharry changed her life, why she refused to put a sign on the building, the secret behind their famous espresso martinis, and how The Red Door became the place everyone ended their night.</p><p>But beneath the success was another story.</p><p>The pressure of running one of Portsmouth's busiest bars... the mental toll of always being "on"... the temptations that came with success... and the unlikely companion that ultimately saved her.</p><p>This isn't just the story of a bar.</p><p>It's about ambition, identity, addiction to momentum, knowing when to let go, and why the places we remember most are often impossible to recreate.</p><p>IN THIS EPISODE:</p><ul><li>Why The Red Door never needed a sign or advertising</li><li>The business philosophy that's made Jay McSharry so successful</li><li>How Portsmouth transformed into a nationally recognized food destination</li><li>The secret behind The Red Door's legendary espresso martinis</li><li>Building a cult following before social media existed</li><li>The hidden cost of success and burnout</li><li>The dog that changed Cresta's life forever</li><li>Why some places become legends—and why they can never truly come back</li></ul><p><br></p><p>CHAPTERS:</p><p>(00:00) Portsmouth's Foodie Boom</p><p>(01:02) Jumpin Jays Changes Game</p><p>(02:06) Jay McSherry Playbook</p><p>(08:48) The Red Door Origins</p><p>(11:52) Designing Speakeasy Vibe</p><p>(14:35) No Signs, No Advertising</p><p>(18:12) Getting Through Loopholes</p><p>(28:55) Big Musical Acts Who Performed There</p><p>(32:00) The Physical & Mental Toll of The Red Door</p><p>(34:20) The Dog Who Saved Her</p><p>(36:45) SPONSORS: <a href="https://www.budgetblinds.com/the-seacoast-nh/?utm_medium=ppc&utm_source=google&utm_campaign=naf-ppc-google-aml-brand-NE-low&utm_content=brand&btype=naf&mgr=aml&clin=us&utm_term=budget%20blinds&utm_query={querystring}&utm_match_type=p&utm_network=g&st-t=tsa&loc_physical_ms=9002432&loc_interest_ms=&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=21214229935&gbraid=0AAAAABxVyXA_P9K9YL_0xrIHQoOjFDSM9&gclid=Cj0KCQjwg5zTBhCLARIsAP2AFU7aPwjzcmUwe7rO5mu5GydvOYrd09L38iM2JgRzC27DwbpETt2sjJAaAp4LEALw_wcB&adw=redirect" target="_blank" rel="ugc noopener noreferrer">Budget Blinds</a> + <a href="https://jobtalkllc.com/" target="_blank" rel="ugc noopener noreferrer">JOBTALK LLC</a></p><p>(39:40) The Red Door's Famous Espresso Martinis</p><p>(44:20) Leaving For New York City</p><p>(50:00) How Portsmouth Has Changed</p><p><br></p><p>SUPPORT SEACOAST STORIES:</p><ul><li>Visit the NEW <a href="https://seacoaststories.com/" target="_blank" rel="ugc noopener noreferrer">SeacoastStories.com</a> for our newsletter & LIMITED-TIME <a href="https://seacoaststories.com/shop?from=newsletter" target="_blank" rel="ugc noopener noreferrer">summer merch drop</a>!</li></ul><ul><li>Follow Seacoast Stories on <a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/seacoast-stories/id1750552627" target="_blank" rel="ugc noopener noreferrer">Apple Podcasts</a> or on <a href="https://open.spotify.com/show/3zg7za9HHoJeuQN3JVTJHN?si=93f6aabdddf442a4" target="_blank" rel="ugc noopener noreferrer">Spotify</a> to get our new episodes every week.</li></ul><p><br></p><p>UPC