3 Years after 10/7 - What's Next for Israel and the Jewish People ╏Eli Lake, Coleman Hughes & Salo Aizenberg

Three years after October 7: What's Next for Israel and the Jewish People.

Noam sits down with Coleman Hughes, Eli Lake and Salo Aizenberg to ask whether the war was worth it. Coleman says Israel traded prestige for power and Hamas did the opposite. Salo brings the Gaza Health Ministry's own 2025 report: 50,000 births, 25,000 deaths, and 108 hospital workers who appear in Hamas's own martyr notices as commanders. Eli says Israel's strategic position has never been better. Noam is the pessimist in the room: "The optimists died in the gas chambers. The pessimists have pools in Beverly Hills." Also: why Hamas never gave up the hostages, John Mearsheimer on tape claiming the IDF killed its own, Coleman's Joe Rogan clip, Noam's 2019 emails that predicted all of it, and a fight over whether Israel should leave the West Bank.

0:00 Three years after October 7: Coleman Hughes, Eli Lake, Salo Aizenberg

2:22 Opening statements: what Israel and Hamas each traded

11:14 Noam: "The optimists died in the gas chambers"

18:41 Why Hamas never released the hostages

33:33 Conspiracy theories and the Mearsheimer tape

47:35 Salo's slides: Gaza's 2025 numbers and the nurses who were Hamas commanders

1:07:09 Should Israel leave the West Bank?

1:21:50 Noam's 2019 emails, Coleman on Rogan, and the diaspora