The Stepbrothers, the Stolen Pickup, and the Nineteen Day Manhunt Across Six States of America

In June 1997, Iowa stepbrothers Jamie McMahan and Christopher Kauffman, driven by a methamphetamine habit and a craving for a green pickup, murdered two women who trusted them, Barbara Garber and Island Schultz, robbed a small town bank, and fled across six states in a nineteen day manhunt that ended in a Pensacola motel through patient hostage negotiation. They pleaded guilty to avoid the federal death penalty and received multiple life sentences, McMahan dying by suicide in prison in 2017 while Kauffman remains incarcerated, leaving a lasting lesson about addiction, misplaced trust, community vigilance, and the partial nature of justice.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/u-s-hidden-crimes--6962513/support.

Got a tip or a case we should investigate? Email us at krimepodcast@gmail.com. We post new episodes every day. Follow and subscribe so you never miss one.

This episode includes AI-generated content.