Traitors Tuesdays: An Apple a Day Sends a Faithful Away

Welcome back to Traitors Tuesdays, where the accusations are flimsy, the apples are deadly, and Jay is somehow still here. Caroline and Phoebe unpack The Traitors: New Blood Episode 5, from a round table that sends the wrong person packing to a murder-in-plain-sight challenge that proves tossing someone an apple is much harder when you’re also trying to kill them.

Jay accuses Katie and Kriste, then votes for Sherry, earning a very deserved dressing-down from Niyyah. Kriste delivers the line of the episode about picking gnat crap out of pepper, Sherry describes Jay’s “crock pot of confusion,” and the Faithful manage to eliminate another one of their own. We have thoughts.

Then the apple toss turns into a full-blown fruit investigation. Victor starts connecting the dots, Tomica starts offering people apples like she’s running a suspicious farmers market, and Caroline has a game-changing theory for how Katie could use the whole mess to her advantage. Meanwhile, the funeral challenge gets genuinely unsettling, the coffin paranoia is real, and Victor’s bathroom humor has officially gone too far.

Plus, we’re picking our murder targets, mourning the scheduling chaos, and launching an ongoing campaign to protect Clyde at all costs.

In the castle, apples are poisoned, the crock pot of lies simmers, and somebody needs to get Jay a new strategy.

XOXO.

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy