Selling Stuff Online Is Weird: Facebook Marketplace, Poshmark & $25 Drama

Big Party is trying to dress like an adult, Molly ordered leopard print corduroys, and somehow we ended up deep in the trenches of Facebook Marketplace, Poshmark, thrift store lighting, lowball offers, and the emotional warfare of selling a kid’s teepee for $25.

Molly is new to the resale game and immediately got hit with the classic “Is this still available?” followed by a lowball and a side of guilt. Big Party, meanwhile, is fully in his hustler era — cleaning shoes, selling clothes, warning everyone about thrift store stains, and reminding us all that Christmas money doesn’t just appear out of thin air.

We’re talking:

- Facebook Marketplace haggling

- Poshmark’s “smart sell” nonsense

- Thrift store finds and resale tips

- Why people negotiate over three dollars

- Leopard pants, leather pants, and adult button-down energy

- The fine line between being nice and being played

Listen or watch the new episode now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, and everywhere you get your podcasts.

Don’t miss out on new episodes of The Big Party Show dropping every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday and The After Party on Tuesdays. Wherever you get podcasts!

The After Party Unfiltered Podcast with Big Party and Molly is coming soon on Thursdays