Reinventing the Pizza Bagel: Bagelverse's Jacob Cooper on Nostalgia and CPG

In this Founder Feature, host Caitlin Bricker sits down with Jacob Cooper, founder of Bagelverse, who's reinventing the classic pizza bagel with real mini New York bagels and bold flavors like spicy vodka and barbecue chicken.

Jacob spent eight years as a CTO in AI and tech before making a complete 180 to chase a childhood nostalgic idea. He launched Bagelverse in April 2026, and in the months since has sold over 80,000 pizza bagels through pop-ups around New York City, won a Shelfie Award, and had one of the most visited booths at Summer Fancy Food.

Caitlin and Jacob dig into his unconventional career pivot, the surprisingly complex supply chain behind a "simple" pizza bagel (which requires two separate co-packers), why packaging might be the single most important investment an emerging brand can make, and how he's building genuine, long-term relationships with retailers a year in advance of launch.

Listen in as they discuss:

Jacob's total pivot from eight years as a CTO in AI and tech to founding BagelverseWhy he built the brand entirely through in-person pop-ups and farmer's markets before ever touching CPGThe surprising complexity behind a "simple" pizza bagel, and why it requires two separate co-packersWhy he intentionally delayed finding a co-packer until he knew the brand had real tractionWhat Jacob learned about follow-up and note-taking after having one of the busiest booths at Summer Fancy FoodWhy big retailers plan shelf resets up to a year in advance, and how that timeline actually works in a founder's favorWhy staying in touch with retailers and buyers without always having an ask builds real, lasting relationshipsWhy Jacob believes packaging is the single most important investment an emerging brand can makeHow Bagelverse is being intentional about which retailers to pursue first, rather than chasing every opportunityWhere to find Bagelverse today, from NYC pop-ups to the brand's farmer's market side project, Little Bagel

Want to connect with buyers, investors, and industry experts in real time?

Join our free Slack community with over 40,000 members. Get access to exclusive events and trade shows where you can meet buyers and investors in person, plus free resources and more.

Just text CPG to 833-605-7002 and we'll get in touch.

Episode Links:

Jacob Cooper LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/pizzabagel-guyBagelverse LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/thebagelverse/homeBagelverse Website: www.thebagelverse.comBagelverse Instagram: @pizzaba